Pledge of Allegiance Blues

October 23rd, 2008  |  by Alive Mind Education  |  published in Pledge of Allegiance Blues

Pledge of Allegiance Blues documents the journey of Rev. Dr. Michael Newdow, the blues-singing California physician and his battle to protect the separation between church and state, a battle that took him all the way to the United States Supreme Court where he defended the landmark “under God” lawsuit. From the controversy over the Ten Commandments monument in the Alabama State Courthouse to a historical analysis about the intertwining of religion and government in American history, Pledge of Allegiance Blues is a smart and funny examination of the often tense relationship between church and state. With toe-tapping musical numbers by Newdow, a cast of characters including attorney Alan Dershowitz, publisher Larry Flynt, and radio talk-show host Sandy Rios, this critically acclaimed documentary provides a contemporary and provocative look at one man’s campaign to defend his constitutional rights.

 
 
 

“Both as a lesson in law and as an entertaining personality profile,
Pledge of Allegiance Blues
is highly recommended.”
3 1/2 stars!
-Video Librarian
 


 


 

Pledge of Allegiance Blues Product Information:


 
Grade Level: AP Government & Politics, AP U.S. History, College and University
Subjects: Culture Studies, Sociology, Religion, American History, Political Issues
Copyright: © 2005 Metro Video Inc. All rights reserved.
Availability: USA and Canada
Set: DVD Only
Total Running Time:
72 minutes
Educational Prices: (includes Public Performance Rights)

  • College / University: $189.00

  • Library / High School: $89.00

    Note: If you are unable to pay via PayPal, please contact info@alivemindeducation.com or call us at 212-398-3112 to order this title.

For public exhibition inquiries please contact us for more details!

Customers who bought Pledge of Allegiance Blues also bought:

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The Atheism Tapes

 
 


Reviews


Video Librarian Review
May/June 2007

Pledge of Allegiance Blues

Rating: 3½ Stars - Highly Recommended

In 2004, the Supreme Court found itself reviewing a potential hot potato case: Sacramento-based, blues-playing physician and lawyer Michael Newdow, a self-described atheist, brought a suit against a California school district to remove the words “under God” from classroom recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance, citing it as a violation of the First Amendment. The court sidestepped the issue via a convenient loophole—claiming that Newdow, who sued the school district where his daughter was enrolled, was not entitled to bring the suit since he was not her custodial parent (his ex-wife had parental authority). But the fact that Newdow came so far to present a cogent argument against the religious assumptions in the Pledge of Allegiance was a testament to his perseverance. Lisa Seidenberg’s documentary portrait is hardly hagiographic: Newdow, though a powerful figure, often comes across as both arrogant and humorless, but he presents his argument with a laser-focused coherence. Of course, not everyone is swayed by Newdow, who maintains a log of hostile voicemail messages from those who seem to be far more interested in childishly demeaning his intellect than realistically challenging his opinions. Newdow obviously enjoys the camera’s attention, and even makes noted legal eagle Alan Dershowitz (who is interviewed here) seem shy and reserved by comparison. Both as a lesson in law and as an entertaining personality profile, Pledge of Allegiance Blues is highly recommended. Aud: C, P. (P. Hall)


Filmmaker Completes ‘Pledge of Allegiance Blues’

by Frank Luongo, Westport News, June 18, 2004

In her recently completed feature-length documentary, Pledge of Allegiance Blues, Westport filmmaker Lisa Seidenberg tells the viewer that most stories begin with either a stranger coming to town or someone going on a journey. “This has both,” the viewer hears her say.

The stranger was Michael Newdow who in the fall of 2002 came to Westport to speak about his successful challenge in federal court to the constitutionality of the phrase “under God” in the saying of Pledge of Allegiance by his daughter’s elementary school class in California.

That decision was set aside Monday on Flag Day by the United States Supreme Court, which found that Newdow did not have the legal standing necessary to bring the case to court because he was not his daughter’s custodial parent.

Seidenberg attended Newdow’s talk out of general curiosity, with no intention of making a movie, but came away launching a film-journey to understand Newdow’s action and to explore the intertwining of religion and patriotism in America.

“I wanted to know what makes someone wake up one morning and sue the Congress and the president before breakfast. I also wanted to know why it bothered people so much,” she says in the film’s narration, her first appearance in one of her own documentaries.

Whether it was just good luck or a residual of good planning, the value of the timing of the Supreme Court’s decision is not lost on Seidenberg in terms of the promotion of the film, which she hopes to sell for commercial distribution.

She will be coming to the movie-market at a time when documentaries are doing well, as evidenced in the critical acclaim for Michael Moore’s Fahrenheit 911, which won “best picture” designation - unusual for a documentary - at this year’s Cannes Film festival and is scheduled for release nationwide June 25.

It was Newdow’s one-person stand, a kind of “Mr. Smith Goes to Washington” story, that interested Seidenberg. “He did it with only a computer, a printer and Google. He set a great example that anyone can go to the Supreme Court.”

Of course Newdow, as Seidenberg was quick to acknowledge, is not just anybody, and that was part of his appeal for a movie-maker.

He has a law degree, but is a physician by profession. He sued on behalf of his daughter’s rights, but was opposed by the girl’s mother, with whom he was estranged and not married. He holds a certificate of ordination for life as a minister of the Universal Life Church, which entitles him to perform weddings, subject to the limitations of state law

To top it off, Newdow wrote folk ballads and strummed a guitar, as he did at the end of his talk in Westport with a rendition of his Pledge of Allegiance Blues.

Seidenberg at once saw she could have an interesting issue, an unusual subject, “like a modern-day Woody Guthrie,” she said, and a jazzy title for a documentary, all in one package.

“A documentary must be entertaining. It can’t be a bitter pill that’s good for you. I wouldn’t watch that kind of movie either,” she said.

“When I first saw the Bill of Rights, I sure had some sleepless nights,” Newdow sings early on in the film, after a scene from an interview with Connie Chung on CNN, in which she said: “Probably a lot of people out there, our viewers in particular, think what you are doing is blatantly anti-American.”

With more than a touch of sass, Newdow shot back: “Those people don’t understand the Constitution, which says that Congress shall make no law establishing religion. I would only ask those people how they would feel if they had to say the Pledge under Sun Myung Moon, David Koresh or Jesus Christ.”

“He touched a sensitive nerve,” according to Seidenberg, and she captured this on film, moving around the country, including a stop in Montgomery Ala. for the public eruption over the removal of stone replicas of the Ten Commandments from a state court house, a furor that included derogatory references to Newdow.

“There’s a larger emotional issue at work. Removing the phrase would threaten some people’s values, even though it wasn’t in the Pledge until 1954,” Seidenberg said. “The Pledge has become an icon for those who see America under siege, alone in the world.”

Although Seidenberg has directed and produced seven documentaries and was the director of photography for six others, Pledge of Allegiance Blues is her first feature-length film.

She called this new film a “great adventure, exploring America. This was really the first time I had looked at my own country.”

Most of her experience has involved filming in China, the Middle East and Russia. Her film, Mongolia on the Edge of Time was shot in one of the remotest places on earth.

The Connecticut Commission on the Arts awarded Seidenberg a fellowship in 2002, and she earned a “Best of Fest” prize from the Rochester International Film and Video competition in 1998, as well as a Bronze Apple Award in the National Educational Film and Video Festival in 1991.

Seidenberg has more than 20 broadcast and cable television credits, including The News Hour with Jim Lehrer. She is a founder and former director of Norwalk’s SoNo Film and Video Festival and was film curator at the Westport Public Library from 1999-2001.

No Comments



Alive Mind eNews
Sign up to receive the latest news
and receive 10% off any DVD order!


Select Reviews
for Alive Mind Education titles


Much of the entertaining Hippie Masala consists of charming reminiscences from the quirky quartet (as well as a pair of voluble South African twins who’ve also taken up residence in India), backed by footage of their day-to-day lives. Recommended.
-Video Librarian November/December 2008

A poignant and serious meditation on human psychology, Protagonist is highly recommended. Editor's Choice.
-Video Librarian September/October 2008

Brilliantly filmed under fairly difficult circumstances, Living Goddess will definitely appeal to anyone with an interest in Eastern religions. Recommended.
-Video Librarian September/October 2008

Some believers will no doubt refuse to watch these conversations, while others may feel that their faith can only be strengthened by confronting the strongest arguments against it—and The Atheism Tapes definitely delivers the latter. Highly recommended.
-Video Librarian July/August 2008

Both as a lesson in law and as an entertaining personality profile, Pledge of Allegiance Blues is highly recommended.
-Video Librarian May/June 2008